The Blind Spot of Optimism: When Faith in the System Becomes a Liability
October 29, 2025 9:03 AM
I’ve been having more and more conversations lately with people who consider themselves liberal, progressive, or left-leaning — and yet, when the topic of the Republican Party or MAGA politics comes up, there’s this surprising optimism. It’s like they still believe that the GOP of Eisenhower or even Reagan is somehow waiting to make a comeback, if only the “crazies” would calm down.
But that’s not how this works anymore.
There’s a kind of cultural optimism — born from the idea that the system ultimately self-corrects — that keeps some people believing that we’ll be fine, even as the modern Republican Party openly embraces authoritarian tactics, voter suppression, and propaganda that would’ve once been unthinkable in mainstream American politics.
I hear it in conversations like one I had recently with a friend who told me, “I don’t think Governor McMaster will sign that total abortion ban — it would make him too unpopular.”
That’s the kind of faith that worries me. It assumes popularity still matters, that a politician will pull back from cruelty or extremism because it might cost votes. But Governor McMaster doesn’t have to care about votes anymore — he’s nearing the end of his final term, wrapping up nearly a decade in power. Ten years is a long time for any governor, especially in a state that desperately needs new ideas and leadership.
At this point, McMaster’s concern isn’t about doing what’s popular; it’s about cementing his legacy among the people who kept him in power. And if signing something like a total abortion ban wins him favor with the most extreme parts of his base, history — or the women of South Carolina — will be the ones paying the price.
You see this same pattern nationally, too. Some well-known pundits and commentators call for “common sense politics” or “balance,” while ignoring that compromise doesn’t work when one side isn’t negotiating in good faith anymore. They want to believe the system they grew up trusting is still capable of self-correction, but the evidence keeps proving otherwise.
And it’s not just pundits. In local communities — at church, on Facebook, at family dinners — that same blind faith lets bad actors off the hook. “He’s just old-fashioned.” “She’s not political.” “They’re just tired of the fighting.” These are the soft excuses that let extremism blend in with everyday conservatism.
What’s really at stake isn’t whether someone calls themselves a liberal or conservative — it’s whether they’re paying attention. Because while some remember when the right-wing fringe was just that — a fringe — it’s now the center of Republican power. The “MAGA base” is the GOP. There’s no moderate wing waiting in the wings to save it.
It’s okay to be optimistic. But optimism without accountability becomes complicity.
We need our friends, families, and communities to stop waiting for a “return to normal.” Normal is gone. The only way forward is to build something better, not to wish the old order back into existence. That means calling out fascism when we see it, rejecting both-sidesism, and holding the line on truth — even when it’s uncomfortable.
That’s not cynicism. That’s realism with purpose. And right now, realism is the most progressive stance there is.